One of the most common dilemmas that clinical researchers face during the analysis phase of clinical trials is the appropriate handling of missing data. Even with the best design and protocols, missing data is often unavoidable in clinical studies running for months or years. Uncorrected missing data can directly interfere with the outcomes and lead to biased inferences. It can reduce the data points and, in turn, reduce the statistical power of the clinical trials.
Nature of Missing Data:
Based on the type of Missing Data, they are categorised into
a) Missing completely at random (MCAR) – means that the missingness is unrelated to any variables.
b) Missing at random (MAR) – implies that it depends on observed variables
c) Missing not at random (MNAR) – indicates that it depends on unobserved factors.
Commonly Used Imputation Methods:
To gain a comprehensive understanding of how to effectively address missing data through statistical analysis, it’s essential to first explore the various methods commonly employed in data management for imputing missing values.
- Mean/Median/Mode Imputation:
Example: If you have a dataset of test scores, and some scores are missing, you can replace the missing scores with the average (mean) score of all the observed scores.
2. Last Observation Carried Forward (LOCF):
Example: In a clinical trial, a patient’s respiratory rate is recorded daily. If a patient misses the assessment on ‘Day 7’, the LOCF method carries forward the ‘Day 6’ data of 18 breaths per minute as the estimate for the missing value on ‘Day 7’.
3. Linear Regression Imputation:
Example: In a study examining the risk factors for cardiovascular disease, missing values for a patient’s cholesterol level can be imputed using linear regression. The model could predict cholesterol level (in milligrams per decilitre) based on their age (in years) and body mass index (BMI) to ensure a comprehensive assessment.
4. K-Nearest Neighbors (K-NN) Imputation:
Example: K-NN can predict missing values for a patient’s reported pain level by considering the pain levels of the five most similar patients in terms of age, gender, and overall health status, allowing for a more complete analysis of the medication’s efficacy.
5. Hot Deck Imputation:
Example: If a patient’s carbohydrate consumption is missing, Hot Deck Imputation can replace it with the carbohydrate intake of a similar patient in terms of age, gender, and body mass index, enabling a more comprehensive analysis of dietary influences on blood sugar control
6. Random Forest Imputation:
Example: When dealing with missing values in a dataset of medical test results, you can use a Random Forest model to predict missing values based on other test results and patient characteristics.
7. Interpolation and Extrapolation:
Example: In a dataset of daily temperature readings, if you’re missing the temperature for a specific hour, you can estimate it by interpolating between the temperatures of the surrounding hours.
8. Impute with the Global Mean:
Example: If some patients have missing heart rate data, the missing values can be replaced with the mean heart rate of all patients in the study, ensuring that every patient has a heart rate value for analysis while assuming an average heart rate for those with missing data.
9. Domain-Specific Imputation:
Example: In a medical dataset, if you’re missing a patient’s blood type but you know their family history and ethnicity, you can use medical guidelines to impute the most likely blood type based on that information.
10. Multiple Imputation:
Example: In a survey dataset with missing income values, you create multiple datasets with different imputed income values for each respondent. You then analyze each dataset separately and combine the results to account for uncertainty in the imputed values.
Handling of Missing Data through Statistical Analysis:
Dealing with missing data is important because it can affect the accuracy and reliability of your analyses. Here are some common methods for handling missing data through statistical analysis:
- Complete Case Analysis (CCA):
Identify and determine the nature of missing data at the first step.
All persons with missing values on one or more variables are excluded from the study. It is used only in early-phase studies of drug development. Though there are drawbacks, CCA can generate valid results in MCAR missing data scenarios and longitudinal data analysis where outcome data are missing.
2. Data Understanding and Preprocessing:
Explore the patterns of missing data. Calculate the percentage of missing values for each variable to assess the extent of missingness. This step helps you prioritize which variables to address and informs your choice of imputation methods. If applicable, perform necessary data preprocessing steps such as data cleaning, transformation, and scaling before addressing missing data. Ensure your dataset is ready for analysis.
3. Imputation:
Choose appropriate imputation methods based on the nature of your data, the missing data mechanism, and the research question.
Here, all the missing data are replaced by real values. In this method, based on the type of value used for replacement, we have a) Single Imputation b) Multiple Imputation (MI)
- In a single imputation, the missing data point is replaced by a single value. Under Single imputation, we have methods such as Last Observation Carried Forward (LOCF), Baseline Observation Carried Forward (BOCF), Worst Observation Carried Forward (WOCF) and Mean Substitution.
- In multiple imputation, a set of values are generated from the predictive distribution and used as a replacement for each of the missing observations. Multiple imputation methods are based on the missing data patterns (monotone, arbitrary) and variable types (nominal, binary, continuous).
Inverse probability weighting, Likelihood-based analysis, Event time analysis, and Non-responder Imputation are few other methods to handle missing data.
4. Impute Missing Data:
Apply the selected imputation methods to fill in missing values in your dataset. Each method will have its own implementation requirements.
5. Sensitivity Analysis:
Conduct sensitivity analyses to assess the impact of different imputation methods on your results. This helps you understand the robustness of your findings.
6. Document Imputation Process:
Clearly document the imputation methods used, the rationale behind your choices, and any assumptions made during the imputation process. Transparent documentation is crucial for reproducibility and the credibility of your analysis.
7. Perform Statistical Analysis:
After handling missing data, proceed with your intended statistical analysis, whether it involves descriptive statistics, hypothesis testing, regression modeling, or any other statistical technique.
8. Interpret and Report Results:
Interpret your analysis results while considering the imputed data. Report any implications of imputation on your findings.
9. Considerations for Reporting:
When reporting your results, disclose the percentage of missing data for each variable, the imputation methods used, and any sensitivity analyses performed.
10. Validation of Assumptions:
Continuously validate assumptions related to the imputed data, such as the normality of imputed variables or the impact on regression assumptions.
11. Consider Prevention:
Recognize that preventing missing data during data collection is often preferable to dealing with it after the fact. Efforts to minimize missing data can lead to more reliable results.
Handling missing data can be complex and cumbersome even after using all the above-mentioned methodologies. For instance, it is not always possible to differentiate between MAR and MNAR. Also, when the data is MNAR, there are no appropriate methods to handle it effectively. Thus, no imputation model is ideal for all missing data problems, but researchers are constantly developing imputation models for various scenarios (multilevel data, questionnaire data). In conclusion, one should understand that prevention of missing data is always better than handling or dealing with missing data.
For more information –
Visit our website – www.paradigmit.com
Or you can write us at ask@paradigmit.com
Follow us for more – https://www.linkedin.com/company/paradigmittechnologyservices/?viewAsMember=true